Did you ever notice that scuba guys are content with cheap guns? I don't think it's because they spend the money on other stuff though. I mean if you're going to spend good money on doing something why would you skimp out on the most important detail, the ultimate reason you're in the water and your only connection to the fish, the speargun. Maybe for a scuba diver the main focus is to get there and then everything else is a secondary matter. Maybe a scuba diver is able to get closer to the fish. Or possibly it's a cultural thing that's just passed on from diver to diver. I understand that the very first guns on the market were JBL, possibly the crappiest gun there is. Another possibility is that the euro pipe guns up until recently were simply too light a tackle for some of the fish we regularly encounter in US waters. The east coast when it comes to spearguns seems to be far behind California where a quality wood gun tradition has long been established. But then again they're mostly freedivers there. Obviously this is the place to discuss spearguns as we all love our guns and have very good reasons for using the ones we do.
From things I learned from Tin Man I started to understand some of the conditions that may preclude freediving in a given area. I'd like to know more about the diving you do to understand why you choose scuba. What is difficult for me to accept is using scuba in up to 60' of depth in good visibility over a nice reef. From my perspective, if you're curious to know my start with diving, there was no great jump I had to make to get in the water and dive. I've been splashing around in sea water since childhood much like kids here splash around in a pool. Difference was that it was much more interesting in the sea and there's a natural inclination to go deeper and see what's down there. I not sure where and how the line is drawn between someone that thinks this way and someone who automatically connects scuba gear with any kind of depth. It probably has to do with where one lives/grows up. But I will tell you that freediving is easy and that I think anyone can do it. Striving to become a better underwater hunter however is a whole other ball game and will keep me motivated for as long as I live.